Illegal migrant with 336 police encounters is still in Germany despite 8 deportation attempts over 20 years

Germany's failed immigration policy is often explained through individual cases like this one involving a man who has been nothing but a burden since he arrived in the country

Dramatic close up of Black man wearing handcuffs on hands, criminal suspect
3 Min Read

A deportation order dating back two decades and 336 encounters with police. Dortmund authorities actually do not even have any idea who he is and have spent years trying to establish his identity and obtain travel documents. Despite their efforts, the man remains in Germany, and all efforts to deport him have been woefully unsuccessful.

The 37-year-old migrant arrived in 2003 as an unaccompanied minor and claimed Moroccan nationality. His asylum claim was rejected, and he has been required to depart since March 2004. Since then, police have recorded 336 contacts with him. Throughout this period, he has never produced a passport and has declined to sign applications for replacement documents.

Dortmund’s mayor, Alexander Kalouti (CDU), confirmed the scale of the effort in a response to a request for information from local Alternative for Germany (AfD) politicians.

An incredible eight formal deportation proceedings were opened against the man, aimed at sending him back to multiple countries, including four aimed at Morocco, two at Algeria, and two at Tunisia, according to German newspaper Ruhr Nachrichten.

The case was also placed in North Rhine-Westphalia’s “case conference” mechanism for especially difficult individual files, with involvement from the interior ministry, police, and immigration authorities dating back to 2019. Embassy screenings and two separate identity-verification processes yielded no usable results. Every procedure ended with a negative reply to the Dortmund immigration office.

Kalouti noted that the city formally requested the man’s cooperation on identity and passport matters 18 times between 2006 and 2026. Authorities state that the main obstacle is insufficient cooperation in clarifying his identity. They claim that without an official travel document, they cannot send the man back to his country of origin.

In fact, Germany may never be rid of him. Melanie Schmickler, head of Dortmund’s migration office, has publicly expressed doubt that deportation will ever succeed.

She described the man as seriously mentally ill and suffering the long-term effects of drug addiction. He has spent periods in clinics and secure psychiatric facilities, has been homeless, and has repeatedly acted chaotically in office appointments to the point that security guards have been forced to remove him. Staff know him by sight.

In fact, once he is released from detention, he may be transferred to a psychiatric facility, where German taxpayers will continue to foot his bill.

This is far from the only case of its type. There have been countless similar cases, such as the one involving a Bosnian man who received over 7,000 euros every month in welfare despite a deportation order dating back 23 years.

Share This Article