Prosecutors in Grenoble have joined those in Valence in arguing there is insufficient evidence to treat anti-white or anti-French racism as an aggravating circumstance in the 2023 killing of 16-year-old Thomas Perotto, despite the testimony of over a dozen witnesses who heard the killers scream anti-white comments.
The new move from the prosecution has set up a key ruling expected next month from the Grenoble Court of Appeal’s Indictment Division, according to French news outlet Europe 1.
The murder case dates back to Nov. 18, 2023, when a large group of individuals with a foreign background descended on a village dance in the small Drôme community of Crépol.
The group of youths attacked the partygoers. During the fight, Perotto, a local high-school student and rugby player, was fatally stabbed. He died while being transported to the hospital. Two other men were critically injured, while several additional victims suffered stab wounds.
Investigating judges charged 11 suspects in juvenile court on charges that included murder and attempted murder. One of the aggravating factors in the case was that the violence was preceded, accompanied, or followed by remarks targeting victims because of their membership in “the white population and the French nation.”
According to the judges’ 300-plus-page report, there were 19 direct witness accounts that included statements such as “We’re here to stab whites.” Additionally, witnesses heard that the suspects wanted to “kill French people” and say “we came to kill white people,” along with similar phrases.
About half of those statements were taken in the hours directly after the murder, lending further credibility to a racist motive. One of the accused also acknowledged that he heard these racist, anti-white remarks from his own group.
The suspects were part of a group that had traveled from the La Monnaie neighborhood of Romans-sur-Isère to gatecrash the village celebration. Although much of the French media initially portrayed the violence as a spontaneous brawl between young people, witnesses described a coordinated attack involving a larger group of Black youths armed with knives.
As Remix News reported, the case gave some hope that crimes involving anti-white racism would finally be recognized in France. However, the move from the prosecution to drop this element of the case is already raising outrage, especially after the judges in the case concluded the accounts showed sufficient consistency to support the racism aggravating circumstance.
Marie-Hélène Thoraval, mayor of nearby Romans-sur-Isère, has publicly criticized what she sees as institutional denial of a racist dimension. In a recent post, she wrote: “Thomas, 3 years of pain and denial! My thoughts are with his family and all the victims of the Crépol ball. I condemn the denial prosecutors are clinging to over this racist crime. Failing to name evil allows it to thrive. Urgent action is needed!”
Thomas, 3 ans de douleur et de déni!
Pensées pour sa famille et pour toutes les victimes du bal de #Crépol.
Je dénonce le déni dans lequel s’enferment les procureurs autour de ce crime raciste. Ne pas nommer le mal, c’est le laisser prospérer. Il y a urgence !
#JusticePourThomas https://t.co/z1sC1VImLt
— mh_thoraval (@MH_Thoraval) November 19, 2026
The Valence public prosecutor’s office has long opposed any finding of racism, describing the relevant testimony of up to 19 witnesses as a “minority” of the total statements collected. It also states that the statements are not reliably attributable to any specific identified suspect.
On Monday, the Grenoble prosecutor-general’s office adopted the same position at a closed-door hearing on appeals from both the defense and the prosecution. It asked the court to drop the racism aggravating circumstance while still sending the case to trial on the other charges.
The Indictment Division is expected to issue a ruling on Dec. 18, which will determine the legal framework of the trial going forward.
Lawyer Thibault de Montbrial, commenting earlier on the investigating judges’ decision to allow the suspects to be charged with hate offenses, said the judges’ decision to even consider a case of anti-white racism was significant, stating, “Crépol represents a turning point. It is the first time investigating judges, at the end of a judicial inquiry, have considered that anti-white racism could have been the motive for a crime.”
